Skip to content

Stop Using Content Scores to Approve SaaS Articles

Our content score rose from 54 to 100 without new facts. See what SaaS teams should check before approving an article.

On this page
  1. What a Content Score Measures
  2. How We Raised Our Own Article From 54 to 100 Without a New Fact
  3. How Much Ranking Articles Repeat Each Other
  4. “Our Writers Need the Score to Know What to Cover”
  5. What to Check Before You Approve a Draft
  6. Frequently Asked Questions

Empact Newsletter

One email a month on what is working in AI search and SaaS go-to-market.

Check your email for a link to confirm your subscription.

You are already subscribed.

Check your email address and try again.

We could not save your subscription just now; please try again.

A content score of 100 means a draft covers what the pages already ranking for its keyword cover. It does not mean the draft tells a reader anything those pages leave out. Our team tested this on one of our own articles, with a grader built the way the vendors describe theirs. Its grade climbed from 54 to 100, and the article gained no new fact.

Use a content score while you research a piece, and approve the piece on what it adds. The terms a score suggests help a writer learn what readers expect to find. At sign-off the number mostly rewards the parts of a draft that repeat page one, which is the opposite of what an editor should be paying for. That claim is about one use of one kind of tool.

I do content marketing for SaaS companies at Empact Partners, writing articles that tell their buyers something page one doesn’t. A grade that rewards repeating the top results pulls a writer back toward what page one already says.

What a Content Score Measures

A content score is a grade, usually out of 100, and a high one does not by itself mean good content. It is built mainly from how closely a draft matches the pages already ranking for its keyword: their words, their headings and their length.

Several tools also grade readability, originality or expertise, often as separate scores. The coverage grade is the part benchmarked against page one, and it is the part argued against here. Six well-known tools say in their own help pages what that benchmark is.

Scroll horizontally to see all columns when the table is wider than this page.

How six content tools build the coverage part of their scores
ToolWhat the coverage score is measured against
SurferThe most optimized pages in the top 10, by default 1
ClearscopeTop-ranking articles, each term weighted by how much competitors use it, with grades up to A++ 2 3
MarketMuseA 50-topic model, scored 0 to 100 relative to the competition 4
FraseThe results page, for its SEO score. Its EEAT (expertise and trust) and GEO (AI answers) scores are separate 5 6
NEURONwriterThe average profile of the top-ranking pages 7
Semrush SEO Writing AssistantYour top-ranking Google competitors. The overall score also weighs readability, originality and tone of voice 8

Surfer’s help center says it most plainly. By default the tool selects the most optimized pages within the top 10. That choice, it says, “should lead you to create a piece of content similar to your competitors that already rank high in Google” 1. Its editor then puts two of those pages’ numbers next to yours.

Surfer’s Content Editor showing a Content Score of 80 out of 100, with a competitor average of 65 and a top competitor at 74 beside it.
Surfer prints the field’s average and its top competitor next to your score.Image from Surfer’s website

Both numbers a writer is asked to beat are made of other people’s pages, so the quickest way past them is to add whatever those pages already contain.

How We Raised Our Own Article From 54 to 100 Without a New Fact

The article was a published llms.txt explainer of ours, about 1,400 words long. We searched the question it answers, “what is llms.txt,” on Google in the US on October 2, 2026. Then we built a grader the way the vendors describe theirs. The grader is our own build and measures only coverage and length:

  • Sample. The ten written pages ranking for the query.
  • Terms. The 60 phrases at least half of those pages use, each with a target set by how often they use it.
  • Score. Out of 100: 80% term coverage, 20% length against the pages’ median.

Our article scored 54. We then had a model rewrite it twice, each time adding the terms the grader reported missing, and after a few minutes of work it scored 100.

54 → 100on our grader, after two model rewrites
1,401 → 2,288words by the grader’s count, 63% longer
11sections added to reach the top score
0facts a reader could not already find on page one
Source: Empact Partners

No claim the rewrite added was new. Each one already sits on one or more of the ten ranking pages. Several were in our article before the rewrite, so the version that scored 100 explains what llms.txt is twice. The page grew 63%, from 1,401 words to 2,288, and gave the reader the same facts in more words.

Then we turned the grader on the ten ranking pages, scoring each one against the other nine. None reached 100, and the highest was 80. The specification that defines llms.txt, ranked first, scored 65, below four pages ranked under it. Videos and a forum thread took some of the top slots, so the ten written pages include results ranked 12, 13 and 14.

Selected Ranking Pages, Scored Against Each Other

Our grader on the ten written pages for “what is llms.txt,” plus our article. Google US, Oct 2, 2026

View the data
LabelValue
Google #1 (the llms.txt spec)65
Google #378
Google #471
Google #755
Google #856
Google #952
Google #1063
Google #1280
Google #1349
Google #1479
Our article, as published54
Our article, padded to 100100
Scores jump up and down the ranking with no pattern, and the last two bars are our article before and after padding.Source: Empact Partners

Our padded version outscored all ten ranking pages we graded, including the document that defined the format. On this query the score did not follow position, and the version on top got there by repeating page one at greater length. That run changed how I use the grade, not whether I use it.

A coverage grade that padding can push to the top still points a writer at a gap. It can’t be the evidence an editor signs off on, because the parts it rewards are the parts a reader already had.

Samantha SpiroSenior GTM Consultant @ Empact PartnersSamantha Spiro on LinkedIn

An editor needs to know what your draft says that the ranking pages leave out, and a coverage score never makes that comparison.

To see that comparison for one of your own articles, run it through our free Information Gain Check below. It sets the piece beside up to eight competing pages, then emails you what only yours says, which points it shares with them and what it could add.

How Much Ranking Articles Repeat Each Other

To check whether the llms.txt result was unusual, we took three SaaS queries on Google US on October 2, 2026. They were “what is lead scoring,” “b2b content strategy” and “how to reduce churn.” We sorted the headings of every article ranking for them into subtopics. The grouping is our judgment, written down rule by rule, and three results pages on one day are a small sample.

More than half of what a ranking article covered, the other articles on its page covered too. Only 18 of the 30 results were written articles. Their headings gave us 280 subtopics in all, counted article by article. Of those, 158, or 56%, were subtopics that at least half of the rival articles also covered.

The share sat within two points across the three queries. Taken one at a time, 15 of the 18 articles spent at least half of their subtopics on that shared ground.

Shared Ground in Each Ranking Article

Subtopics at least half its rivals also cover. 18 articles, 3 queries, Oct 2, 2026

View the data
LabelValue
Lead scoring #150%
Lead scoring #250%
Lead scoring #562%
Lead scoring #667%
Lead scoring #980%
Lead scoring #1042%
Content strategy #260%
Content strategy #367%
Content strategy #467%
Content strategy #546%
Churn #253%
Churn #353%
Churn #469%
Churn #659%
Churn #754%
Churn #869%
Churn #959%
Churn #1048%
Whatever the query, a typical ranking article spends half or more of its outline on subtopics its rivals cover too.Source: Empact Partners

The count only tells us which subtopics each article takes up. Two pages can share a subtopic and still disagree about it, and the count cannot say whether content scores caused the overlap. On these three queries, it shows how little open ground is left for a draft built from the same pages.

That ground sat in the subtopics only one result covered. They were mostly frameworks, opinions, first-hand stories and product pitches, and none of them was a measurement the publisher had made itself. Our grader only counts phrases that at least half the ranking pages share, so it has no way to reward a subtopic for being the one nobody else covers.

“Our Writers Need the Score to Know What to Cover”

The objection is practical, and it is strong. Writers who are not subject experts miss questions every reader asks. Briefs without a target drift. A content lead checking forty drafts a month cannot read each one against the results page, and the score is one standard the lead can apply to all forty.

That argument is right about the problem, and we once ran its solution ourselves. In 2023 our team’s method for reaching 100 was to export the tool’s suggested keywords and have ChatGPT write the sections they implied.

The number went green, and we thought pairing the two tools was the clever part. As a test for approving a draft, the score has three real strengths and three real weaknesses.

Pros

  • It finds gaps, since a term you never used is sometimes a question your reader asks
  • It teaches a writer new to the subject the words readers use for it
  • It scales to every draft without an expert reading each one

Cons

  • Our own article reached 100 in two rewrites with nothing new in it
  • The page ranked first scored below four pages ranked under it on our grader
  • A coverage grade cannot tell whether a claim in the draft is supported

All three pros help before and during drafting, and a missing term can still flag a gap in an edit. None of them tells an editor whether the draft contributes anything, which is the question at sign-off.

Google’s guide to helpful content asks a question no coverage score can answer: “Does the content provide original information, reporting, research, or analysis?” 9 That is guidance rather than a description of how Google ranks pages, but it names what the number cannot see.

NEURONwriter, which sells a score, draws the same limit on its own site, for its own customers: “Scores can show useful gaps. They cannot make decisions for you.” 10

A content score measures how closely a draft matches the pages already ranking, so it should never be the reason a draft gets approved.

SEO practitioners on Reddit draw the same line between research and approval. Two of them describe studying the search engine results page (the SERP) to learn what a query wants, and a third asks the approval question outright.

Tips from Reddit

What SEO practitioners say about content tools

Should be doable to replicate, before Surfer I made content briefs manually just with less details. Process was roughly the same, examine top ranking content, identify patterns, and improve on it. Just took a lot of time.

r/SEO, u/TwofacedDisc, April 2026

SERP analysis is mostly to check what Google is serving (the different intent for the keyword). You can do this in 1 min top without even opening any page. I don't go around looking at every page to make a summary of their content or copy their headings.

r/SEO, u/SanRobot, April 2026

Does it provide any info beyond what somebody would find on that product's page?

r/bigseo, u/HustlinInTheHall, August 2023

The first two use the top-ranking pages to plan a brief or read a query’s intent, without copying anyone’s headings. The third was a reply to someone whose page every tool said should rank, and its question is the one an approval step exists to ask.

What to Check Before You Approve a Draft

Approval needs a reader who did not write the draft and who reads it against the results page. The writer’s part comes earlier. After reading the top results, they name in the brief what the piece will add.

At sign-off, the reader checks that the addition made it into the draft with its evidence. When an AI agent writes the first draft, the person who does this read is what we call a consultant in the loop. Five checks cover what the draft adds.

Before a draft is approved

  • It says at least one thing none of the ranking pages says
  • That new part is backed inside the draft by a number your company counted, a test you ran, a worked example from real work or an expert’s own words
  • It names the step readers get wrong, where the topic has one
  • Someone who did not write it has read it against the results page
  • The score’s suggested terms were read, and kept only where they answer this reader

One partner’s blog shows what the first check looks like when every article has to pass it. For Feathery, a form builder, we made every article give its readers something a competitor’s generic “Top 10 Form Builders” listicle could not.

That meant demos readers could try inside nearly every post, Feathery’s own forms built into the pages, and real case studies and first-hand expertise added to each piece. The Feathery case study reports more than 300% organic traffic growth and over 5.5 million impressions in 16 months 13. Those numbers cover the whole partnership, not this check alone.

If we judged your drafts this way, we would start with the slowest of the five checks, the read against every ranking page. We would give its first pass to the agent behind the Information Gain Check above, which we run in full for partners, and a person would still make the call. Here are the four parts of that approval step when we run it with your team.

Your approval step, run with Empact Partners

  • Each article’s angle comes from what your experts tell us in interviews
  • A review agent reads every draft against the pages that already rank and marks where it repeats them
  • The writing system we build for you drafts and reviews each piece against a written rulebook and the claims your team approved
  • Your named consultant decides when each piece ships, once that read is done

The number itself never decides. Its suggested terms help while a piece is researched and edited. The drawing below follows a draft from research to sign-off, and every step after research asks what the draft adds.

Flow: research with the score’s suggested terms, a brief naming what the draft adds, a review agent marking repeats and unsourced claims, then a consultant’s read that ships the draft or returns it.
Every step after research judges what the draft adds, and someone other than the writer decides whether it ships.

A draft that fails the last step goes back to its brief, where the missing contribution gets named, rather than back to the missing terms for another pass.

Deciding what that contribution should be is where the playbook below helps your own writers. It shows how to write an article that adds what AI answers lack, and how to check that ChatGPT and Google AI Mode quote it correctly.

So keep the tool open while your writers research, and take its number out of the approval meeting. Before the next draft goes up for sign-off, ask its writer what it says that the ten pages above it do not. Then ask where in the draft the proof of that sits. If neither answer comes quickly, the draft is not ready for sign-off.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should we cancel our content optimization tool?

Keep it if your writers open its suggested terms while they research and brief, which is where it pays its way, especially for writers who are new to a subject. If the only job left for it is grading finished drafts, retire that job first. Then look at the subscription again after a quarter. If nobody looked at the suggested terms during research in that time, the tool was only ever an approval gate, and you have already replaced it.

What should replace the score in our approval checklist?

Two questions the editor answers from the draft itself. First, what does this draft say that none of the pages ranking for its keyword say? Second, where in the draft is the evidence for that part: a figure you counted, a test you ran, an example from a named project or an expert’s words? Add a third line naming the reader who signs it off, someone who did not write it, so the check has an owner before the draft exists.

What if we have no original data to add?

Data is one kind of evidence, and most teams hold others they never use. The engineer who built the feature knows the trade-off behind it, support knows the step users get wrong, and sales knows the objection that stalls deals. One focused conversation with any of them can give a draft something no ranking page has. A draft with none of these should wait until it does, because publishing it adds one more copy of page one.

Who on our team should give the final yes on a draft?

Someone who knows the subject, did not write the draft and is named in the brief before drafting starts. That can be a senior editor or a product marketer, with a subject expert checking the claims in their own field. A small team can give the job to the writer’s manager, as long as they read the results page before the draft. Others can review it, but name one person who gives the final yes, because a draft that four people approve has no single owner.

Could a review agent sign off drafts without a person?

No. A review agent can hold a draft against its research notes and the ranking pages, then mark passages that repeat what is already published and claims with no source. That shortens the reviewer’s read. Whether a contribution is worth publishing, or still holds after your latest release, is a judgment someone has to answer for. So a named person makes the call, and starts from the agent’s marks.

Will approving drafts without a score change our rankings or AI citations?

Nobody can promise that, and our experiment tested how easily a score inflates, not traffic or citations. What changes is what you publish: drafts that give a reader something the results page does not. Judge the change on your own pages over a quarter or two. Compare articles approved the new way with older ones on the same topics, and look first at the queries where a draft added something the top results lack.

Do content scores affect Google rankings?

None of the six vendors’ help pages cited here says Google uses its score. They describe it as a comparison with the pages that already rank. Our own grader put the top result for its query below four pages ranked under it. One query is a small sample, but it is reason enough to stop reading a score as a forecast of position. Treat it as a measure of how closely a draft resembles the current results.

How do we brief writers who aren’t experts in the subject without a score?

Keep the suggested terms in the brief as a map of what readers expect, then add the part no term can supply. Name one expert the writer must interview, or one real example they must work through, and write the article’s contribution into the brief before drafting starts. The writer then knows both what the field covers and what their draft must add. The editor gets a line in the brief to check the draft against.

Is a rising content score ever a warning sign?

Yes, when the score rose and nothing new arrived with it. A big jump between two versions can mean a writer, or a model, worked through the missing terms one by one, which is how our own test reached the top. Before you accept the new version, read only the passages added since the last one. If each of them sits on a ranking page already, the draft just got longer, and the next revision should take them back out.

What does a review agent need from our team before it can mark drafts?

Three things most teams already have. Your research notes and interview transcripts tell it what each piece should add. The claims your team approved about the product, with their sources, let it flag a sentence that goes further. Your published pages let it tell a repeat of your own blog from a repeat of a rival’s. Without the notes, an agent can see what a draft repeats but not whether it delivers what its brief promised.

Sources (13)
  1. Surfer, "Answering Your Most Frequent Content Score Questions" (2026)↩1↩2
  2. Clearscope, "How does Clearscope grade your content?" (2026)↩1
  3. Clearscope, "Editing and Optimizing Your Content" (2026)↩1
  4. MarketMuse, "What is Content Score?" (2026)↩1
  5. Frase, "Content Scores Explained" (2026)↩1
  6. Frase, "Optimize Existing Content" (2026)↩1
  7. NEURONwriter, "How NEURONwriter Uses TF-IDF & BM25 to Measure True Content Relevance" (2026)↩1
  8. Semrush, "What is SEO Writing Assistant and how does it work?" (2026)↩1
  9. Google Search Central, "Creating Helpful, Reliable, People-First Content" (2026)↩1
  10. NEURONwriter, "How can I optimize my blog posts for SEO?" (2026)↩1
  11. Empact Partners, "Content-Score Experiment on Our llms.txt Article" (2026)Empact Partners' own data↩1↩2the article scored on our own term-coverage grader against the ten written pages ranking for the query what is llms.txt on Google US, before and after two model rewrites, with each page also scored against the other nine; run on October 2, 2026.
  12. Empact Partners, "Audit of Three SaaS Results Pages" (2026)Empact Partners' own data↩1the headings of the 18 written articles ranking for the queries what is lead scoring, b2b content strategy and how to reduce churn on Google US, grouped into subtopics by our team; run on October 2, 2026.
  13. Empact Partners, "Feathery: From Early Stage To 7-Figure ARR" (2026)Empact Partners' own data↩1

Ready
To Connect?

Let's Partner