Skip to content

How to Judge Your First Quarter of Mention Building

See what a mention-building quarter can deliver, what AI visibility cannot prove, and when to renew or change the plan.

On this page
  1. What the Research Says Mentions Do for AI Visibility
  2. Why the Same Question Gets Different Answers Each Time
  3. How to Plan the Thirteen Weeks of a First Quarter
  4. Which Pages a First Quarter Should Go After
  5. Questions to Bring to the Renewal Call
  6. Deciding What the Next Quarter Is For
  7. Frequently Asked Questions

Empact Newsletter

One email a month on what is working in AI search and SaaS go-to-market.

Check your email for a link to confirm your subscription.

You are already subscribed.

Check your email address and try again.

We could not save your subscription just now; please try again.

The first renewal of a mention-building retainer comes due around week thirteen, and the results it was bought for don’t run on the contract’s clock. Mention building means getting your brand named on pages you don’t own, such as best-of listicles and reviews, with or without a link.

Publishers post agreed pieces on their own schedules, and AI engines pick pages up on theirs. So the report on the renewal call can be all activity, such as a count of outreach emails and a podcast that won’t air until next month. Meanwhile ChatGPT still recommends three competitors, and the CFO wants a decision. None of that means anyone lied.

Nobody can promise a new position in ChatGPT inside 90 days either, because nobody controls which pages an engine reads for a given answer. A vendor can still promise you evidence you can check yourself. Hold any vendor’s first quarter to these four items:

What a first quarter should hand you

  • A baseline of your buyers’ category questions, each asked enough times to see which brands and pages the engines lean on
  • A target sheet of listicles and review pages those answers already cite, each with the answer that cited it
  • Outreach to each editor on that sheet, with every agreement and publication date on record
  • A second reading of the same questions, with each live placement checked against the pages the answers cite

I’m Samantha Spiro of Empact Partners, where we do mention building for SaaS companies. Those four items are the test I’d want any first quarter held to at renewal, ours included.

What the Research Says Mentions Do for AI Visibility

The pages you don’t own range from best-of listicles and reviews to articles, podcasts and community threads. For AI visibility, start with the listicles, because one of them can sit under many answers. In the run described below, a single best-of roundup was cited in five of eight ChatGPT answers to the same buying question.

One large study comes from Ahrefs, which analyzed 75,000 brands and found that the ones named often across the web also showed up more often in Google’s AI Overviews. Ahrefs adds that the data shows a correlation and can’t prove the mentions caused the visibility 1.

So mentions and AI visibility travel together, but I haven’t found a published study that says what one quarter of new mentions will do for your brand. When I read a vendor’s target sheet, I don’t start from the studies:

For every page a vendor targets, I want to see the AI answer that cited it. If a vendor can’t show you that for your category, the study they quote has nothing to say about what their quarter will change for you.

Samantha SpiroSenior GTM Consultant @ Empact PartnersSamantha Spiro on LinkedIn

Why the Same Question Gets Different Answers Each Time

Checking which pages AI answers cite means reading those answers, and AI answers vary from one run to the next, even when nothing about your brand has changed. That spread sets the bar for any result, since a move smaller than the usual spread can’t be read as progress yet.

On October 2, 2026, we asked ChatGPT four buyer questions eight times each, with web search on. The questions asked for the best CRM, help desk, project management tool and System and Organization Controls 2 (SOC 2) compliance software for a small software company. SOC 2 is the security audit startups face when they sell to larger companies.

We recorded every brand named and every page cited 2. That’s 32 answers from one engine on one day, enough to see the variation and nowhere near enough to rank anyone. Two or three vendors per question were named in all eight answers, and the rest came and went:

Scroll horizontally to see all columns when the table is wider than this page.

Vendors ChatGPT named across eight runs of each buyer question, October 2, 2026
CategoryNamed in all 8 answersNamed in some of them
CRMHubSpot, PipedriveAttio 7, Close 7, Salesforce 4, Zoho CRM 1
Help deskIntercom, Help Scout, ZendeskFreshdesk 7, HubSpot Service Hub 3, Front 2, Crisp 1
Project managementLinear, Jira, ClickUpGitHub Projects 7, Asana 6, monday.com 1
SOC 2 complianceVanta, Drata, SecureframeSprinto 7, Thoropass 2

The pages behind those answers matter as much as the names. Four more numbers from the same run matter when you plan a quarter:

5different sets of vendors from eight runs of the CRM question
3 to 7sources cited under each answer
5 of 8CRM answers citing one roundup published in June
2 daysafter it was published, a help desk roundup was already cited
Source: Empact Partners

Read together, those numbers say three things about your own quarter. A single answer is only one sample, so a screenshot of one answer proves nothing about where you rank. Each answer leans on a handful of pages, so a short target sheet built from those pages is worth more than a long one built for volume.

And a page published this month can already be cited, so a placement that goes live in week nine isn’t too late to count. The ages of the cited pages point the same way. Of the 30 third-party pages that carried a publication date, 11 were under three months old, as the chart shows.

How Old ChatGPT’s Cited Pages Were

30 dated third-party pages, 32 answers to four software questions, Oct 2, 2026

View the data
LabelValue
Under 30 days4
31 to 90 days7
91 to 180 days13
Over 180 days6
Four of the cited pages were under a month old, so a placement can count in the quarter it goes live.Source: Empact Partners

Because single answers vary this much, your AI share of voice has to be read across many runs of many questions. The phrase also covers two different measures, and a quarter’s report should keep them apart:

Our October run was one engine on one day. Watching share of answers over weeks means asking the same questions again and again. We built the Empact Panel to do that, putting each partner’s buyer questions to the engines every week and keeping every answer with its sources.

The card below is one software partner’s example, with 1,000 questions tracked on two of those engines. It shows two other kinds of movement, between engines and between weeks. Partners stay anonymous in these examples, so “Partner” stands where its name was.

Brand Visibility card for one software partner: 2.1% of ChatGPT and 5.9% of Google AI Mode answers to 1,000 questions name it, nine readings from September 2 to November 12
Empact Panel example: Google AI Mode names this software partner in 5.9% of answers and ChatGPT in 2.1%, asked the same 1,000 questions.Empact Panel

Two things in that card matter for a first-quarter review. Google AI Mode names the partner almost three times as often as ChatGPT on identical questions, so each engine gets read on its own.

The line also moves between readings. It dips through late September and October, then climbs back by mid-November. A slide showing only the October readings would make that look like a sharp fall. Whatever caused each move, one reading in week thirteen can’t tell you which way the quarter went.

How to Plan the Thirteen Weeks of a First Quarter

Variation isn’t the only reason one reading settles little. There’s also the wait between an editor’s yes and a citation. After an editor agrees, three things still have to happen. The publisher posts the page, search engines index it, and an engine picks it for a given answer.

Google’s guidance for AI Overviews and AI Mode sets one technical condition: the page must be indexed and able to show in ordinary results with a snippet 3. The drawing below marks where the vendor’s part of that chain ends.

Five steps from a chosen page to a possible citation. The vendor chooses the target and wins the editor's agreement, and then the page publishes, search indexes it and an answer may cite it.
An editor’s yes starts a wait, since the page still has to publish, get indexed and be picked by an engine.

The vendor owns the choice of pages and the pitching that wins each yes, so those are the steps to hold a vendor to. The rest can be measured but not promised. Here’s the sequence I’d plan a first quarter around. The weeks are my estimate, not an average from data, and they shift because most steps depend on people outside your company.

Scroll horizontally to see all columns when the table is wider than this page.

A first-quarter plan: the work, what you get and what it depends on
WeeksThe workWhat you getWhat it depends on
1–2Your category questions go to the engines repeatedly, and an audit shows where you’re already namedA baseline, with the raw answers keptYour choice of the buyer questions that matter
2–3The vendor names the cited listicles, reviewers and writers, and your marketing lead approves the targetsA target sheet, each target with the answer that cited itPages the engines cite
3–8The vendor pitches each editor by hand, and your lead approves each pitchReplies, requests and agreed placementsProduct access, a reviewer, someone worth quoting
6–10Publishers put the agreed pieces liveThe first live mentions, each with its dateEach publisher’s own schedule
8–13Search engines index the pages, and answers may cite themCited answers, if engines pick the pagesCrawling, indexing and each engine’s choices
13The same questions go out the same way and get compared with week oneA reading and next quarter’s planMeasurement that matches the baseline

Whoever pitches should log every reply, request and agreed date as it happens. Lined up each week against the latest AI answers your buyers see, a log like that is what a mid-quarter report comes from. Ask for that report in week seven rather than at the renewal call.

It will be shorter than a slide of email counts, and every line of it can be checked:

What an honest week-seven report names

  • The pages you’re trying to land on, each with the answer that cited it
  • Which editors replied, and what they asked for
  • A publication date for every placement that’s been agreed
  • What is live, kept apart from what is promised

Which Pages a First Quarter Should Go After

Every line of that report depends on the target sheet, so a quarter’s first job is finding the pages your buyers’ answers already cite. In the October run, one CRM roundup was cited in five of the eight CRM answers, and one help desk roundup in five of the eight help desk answers 2.

A roundup cited that often is worth more to your quarter than a new article no answer cites yet. That’s why the first emails should go to the editors of existing relevant listicles your buyers’ answers keep citing, each with a case for adding your product.

You can run a first version of that search yourself before you judge any vendor’s target sheet. Our Listicle Inclusion Report asks for your website and work email. It finds the best-of listicles AI engines and Google show for your category, which companies each one already includes, and a way into the ones that leave you out.

Once you have the listicles, you’ll find that some sell their spots, either a place in the roundup or a higher rank. Before any money changes hands, ask how the payment is labeled to readers and whether it sets the order.

The US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) publishes guides on endorsements, with an example of a review site that ranks products by payment. The guides call those rankings deceptive and say a disclosure of the payments wouldn’t fix them. They add that the brand that paid may also be held liable 4. Get a lawyer’s read before you pay for any placement.

The alternative to paying is giving editors a reason to add you. A newsworthy asset, such as a launch with a real hook or original research writers want to cite, gives the person pitching more to offer. It still won’t guarantee that any editor says yes.

Questions to Bring to the Renewal Call

At the renewal call, judge whether the agreed work happened on the right pages separately from what the readings show. The placements can be on the right pages before the readings have had time to move.

Flat visibility after one quarter doesn’t tell you whether the work was aimed at the right pages.

Branded search, AI referral traffic and pipeline belong in the review too, in a column of their own beside the scorecard. Track them from week one, with no promised date for when they’ll move. The scorecard I’d bring to the call covers the work and the readings:

Scroll horizontally to see all columns when the table is wider than this page.

The renewal scorecard: the question, the evidence to ask for and what a no means
QuestionThe evidence to ask forIf the answer is no
Was a baseline taken?The questions, the engines, the number of runs and the raw answersNothing later can be judged, so fix the measurement first
Were the targets chosen from citations?For each target, the answer that cited itChange the targets
What’s live, and when is the rest due?Each placement’s address, its status and a publication date for anything still agreedA slow publisher is normal. A placement with no date or no named publisher isn’t
Do live placements sit on cited pages?Your live placements matched against the pages your questions cite todayTheir reach is unconfirmed, so check those pages across more runs before dropping them
Did visibility move beyond ordinary variation?The same questions, asked the same way, against the baselineFlat alone doesn’t settle a first quarter
Did your team supply what outreach needed?Product access, a reviewer, someone to quote, approvals within daysFix your side before you judge the vendor’s

Mention building borrows its pitching from public relations (PR), and people who work in PR back up two rows of that scorecard from the vendor’s side of the table. These come from a thread where the founder of a bootstrapped SaaS company, 13 months into a $5,200-a-month PR retainer, asked whether they were expecting too much:

Tips from Reddit

What PR practitioners say about judging a retainer

Tiers of coverage could be fine, as is targeting specific publications, but we can never guarantee a placement in a specific outlet.

r/PublicRelations, u/Laszlo-Panaflex, May 2025

I have found when clients aren't very involved in helping me do my job, and have little to share to help me do my job better, coverage definitely declines.

r/PublicRelations, u/charshaff, May 2025

From 20yrs working with start-ups, the biggest problem is founders thinking what is news for them should be newsworthy for journalists, and that just isn't how it works.

r/PublicRelations, u/BCircle907, May 2025

Take the first comment. No one can promise a particular outlet in advance, so the scorecard asks about placements an editor has already agreed to, and when each one is due. Those dates also show when a quarter is slipping.

A quarter is on schedule when it has a clean baseline and cited targets, and agreed placements go live on the editors’ dates. That holds even if ChatGPT hasn’t noticed yet. Agreements with no date, dates that pass without a word and delays nobody wrote down are slippage, whatever the slide says.

The second comment matches the scorecard’s last row. Coverage depends partly on what your team gives the person pitching, so a quarter short of product access or quotes says as much about your side as the vendor’s. The third is a warning about the newsworthy asset above, since what is news to you may not be news to an editor.

Deciding What the Next Quarter Is For

The renewal call has three honest outcomes, and each comes with a condition you can check:

  • Renew when the baseline was taken properly, the targets came from cited pages, and editors of those pages have agreed to placements that are live or still on their dates.
  • Change the targets when the work is real but aimed at pages your buyers’ answers don’t cite.
  • Stop when nobody can name the targets or show what has been agreed.

If the call ends in a stop or a change, the next step can be a smaller test, and the playbook below walks through one. You audit any link building you already pay for, test mentions on a few pages your buyers’ answers cite and decide from the results. It also helps if you’re still weighing mention building against link building for the same budget.

A first quarter with Empact Partners would open on your baseline, because nothing at the renewal call can be judged without it. From there we do the measuring, and you get reports that put every live placement next to what the engines told your buyers that week.

Expect the same from any proposal you read. If it promises a visibility lift by a set date, it is promising something no vendor controls, so ask it to name the baseline and the number of runs instead.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should we renew if our AI visibility hasn’t moved after three months?

Not on that number alone. In the plan above, placements go live from week six at the earliest, and each engine picks pages up on its own schedule. A flat line in week thirteen is what a quarter on schedule can look like.

Check the work behind the line instead. Were the targets taken from cited pages, have editors agreed to placements on those pages with dates, and was the reading taken the same way as week one? If all three hold, renew and read again next quarter. If the targets were never cited, change them before you spend more.

How many mentions should a first quarter produce?

No count carries over from one company to the next. It depends on how many cited listicles your category has, what you can offer their editors and how quickly those editors work.

Nobody should promise you a number. Ask instead for the target pages and, for each agreed placement, the publication date the editor gave. The vendor chooses the first and can document the second, so those are what you can hold it to at the renewal call.

Once a placement is live, how soon can it show up in AI answers?

There’s no fixed delay. On Google, the page first has to be indexed and able to show in search with a snippet. Google adds that meeting those requirements doesn’t guarantee its AI features will use the page 3. Google is the only engine whose rule I can point to.

In our October run, a roundup published two days before was already cited, so it can be quick. Treat that as what’s possible rather than what’s typical. Check each live placement across several runs of your questions over the following weeks.

Why does ChatGPT name different tools each time we ask the same question?

Each answer is generated fresh, and with web search on the engine can read a different set of pages each time. In our October run, eight runs of the CRM question gave five different sets of vendors.

One answer is a sample, so ask each question several times on the same settings before you call anything a gain or a loss. A screenshot from one morning tells you what one run said and nothing more.

What changes in the second quarter if the first one went to plan?

Very little in the measurement, and that’s deliberate. The same questions go to the same engines with the same settings, so every reading stays comparable with week one.

The targets grow to the next pages the answers cite. The first quarter’s placements keep being read across more runs, since a page can take weeks to start appearing. Branded search and AI referral traffic stay in their own column. Read them for a direction once placements have been live for a while, without a date set in advance.

What does our team need to have ready before outreach starts?

Four things decide how fast editors say yes. Reviewers want product access to test it, writers want numbers worth citing, and many pieces need a person who can be quoted.

The fourth is one reviewer, often the marketing lead, who approves each pitch within a couple of days. In the plan above, most of the pitching happens in weeks three to eight, so approvals that wait a week each eat into the time left for replies and publication.

What counts as a placement in the quarter’s report?

Only a live page that names you. A recorded podcast, an agreed article or a promised update to a listicle is an agreement in progress. It belongs in the report with its expected date and moves to live on the day it publishes.

Keeping the two apart lets you tell a slow publisher from a plan that has stalled. It also stops a quarter of promises from reading like a quarter of results.

Should pipeline and revenue be part of the first-quarter review?

Track them from week one, in their own column, but don’t expect them to settle a first quarter. If placements move branded search, AI referral traffic or pipeline at all, it happens after the pages go live, through people reading them or AI answers citing them. That chain can run well past week thirteen.

Read them alongside the placements over the next two or three quarters. Ask new buyers where they first saw you, too, because one who read an AI answer may arrive by typing your name into search.

What if the vendor’s target sheet doesn’t match the pages our answers cite?

Ask for the answer that cited each target. Replace the ones no answer cites, keep the placements already agreed, and move the freed outreach time to cited pages that leave you out.

Before you drop a page, check it across more runs, since a page missing from a handful of answers can still turn up in others. A vendor that can’t show where its targets came from hasn’t shown why those pages matter to you.

Which AI engines should the baseline cover?

The ones your buyers use, and your sales calls are the quickest way to learn which those are. ChatGPT and Google AI Mode are a sensible start for most software categories, with Claude or Perplexity added when buyers mention them.

Read each engine on its own, because identical questions can produce very different shares on two engines. Put the same questions to each with the same settings, several times, in week one and again in week thirteen.

Sources (4)
  1. Ahrefs, "An Analysis of AI Overview Brand Visibility Factors (75K Brands Studied)" (2025)↩1
  2. Empact Partners, "ChatGPT buyer-question panel" (2026)Empact Partners' own data↩1↩2↩3↩4four buyer questions asked eight times each through DataForSEO’s ChatGPT scraper, US English, web search on, 32 answers, every brand named and every page cited recorded, October 2, 2026.
  3. Google Search Central, "AI features and your website" (2025)↩1↩2
  4. US Federal Trade Commission, "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising, 16 CFR Part 255" (2023)↩1

Ready
To Connect?

Let's Partner